The Supreme Court questioned the obligation to illegal entrants during a hearing on Rohingya disappearances. The court asked if ‘intruders’ should receive a ‘red carpet welcome’. The bench emphasized that if individuals lack legal status, deportation is a valid consideration. The court pondered the implications of illegal entry followed by demands for legal protections. Supreme Court The Supreme Court on Tuesday took a sharp stance while hearing a habeas corpus plea alleging the custodial disappearance of Rohingya individuals and seeking that any deportation follow due process, asking whether “intruders” should be given a “red carpet welcome,” as reported by LiveLaw.Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, sitting with Justice Joymalya Bagchi, questioned the basis of the plea, asking, “Where is the order of the Government of India declaring them (Rohingyas) as refugees? Refugee is a well defined legal term… If there is no legal status of a refugee, and somebody is an intruder, and he enters illegally, do we have an obligation to keep that fellow here?”The petitioner’s counsel clarified that no refugee status was being sought — only that deportation must follow law.LiveLaw quoted the bench saying: “If they don’t have legal status to stay in India… If an intruder comes, do we give them a red carpet welcome saying we would like to give you all facilities? What is the problem in sending them back?”CJI Kant further remarked on illegal entry, saying: “First you enter, you cross the border illegally… Then you say, now that I have entered, your laws must apply to me… Do we want to stretch the law like this?”About the AuthorTOI News DeskThe TOI News Desk comprises a dedicated and tireless team of journalists who operate around the clock to deliver the most current and comprehensive news and updates to the readers of The Times of India worldwide. With an unwavering commitment to excellence in journalism, our team is at the forefront of gathering, verifying, and presenting breaking news, in-depth analysis, and insightful reports on a wide range of topics. The TOI News Desk is your trusted source for staying informed and connected to the ever-evolving global landscape, ensuring that our readers are equipped with the latest developments that matter most.”Read MoreEnd of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideos’Op Sindoor Drew Red Line’: Israeli Expert On India-Israel Ties, Defence Tech, China-Pakistan ThreatPolitical Storm Over Sanchar Saathi As Opposition Calls It A Snooping Tool, Govt Defends MoveAt UAE National Day, Piyush Goyal Says India-UAE Alliance Is Global Template For Trust, Innovation’India Values Thailand As Important Maritime Neighbour’: Jaishankar In Bilateral Talks With Thai FMIndia Stands Strong with $18B Russia Energy Investment, Ex-Envoy Malhotra ConfirmsWatch: MPs Speak Out as SIR Row Dominates Winter Session OpeningIndia’s Elections Earn Global Praise, CEC Calls It A ‘Moment Of Pride’ Amid Vote Row ClaimsHaryana Bodybuilder Killed After Standing Up To Harassers; Family Says Attack Was Planned MurderModi Trolls Opposition Over Bihar Setback Days Before Parliament ShowdownWoman Marries Boyfriend’s Corpse After Family Kills Him, Alleges Police Provoked Brother123Photostories5 places in India that look completely different at 6 AM and 6 PMEggs and high cholesterol: What’s safe and what’s not (expert tips)Why Maharashtra’s Vadhvan Port may become India’s next global gateway — Adani’s big maritime plans explained6 Everyday mistakes that secretly slow down your metabolism6 K-dramas that bring the ultimate Christmas vibe: From ‘Goblin’ to ‘Winter Sonata’Dare to Look Down? Vizag Unveils India’s Longest Glass Skywalk; a 262m Cliff-Edge Walk of Pure ThrillNot oranges, these 10 foods have the highest amount of Vitamin CVivek Agnihotri’s ‘The Kashmir Files’ to Ayushmann’s ‘Vicky Donor’: Low-Budget films that became massive hits5 effective Shani remedies to remove obstacles from your life9 reasons to make your child eat almonds every morning123Hot PicksParliament Winter SessionCyclone DitwahWorld NewsGold rate todaySilver rate todayPublic Holidays NovemberBank Holidays NovemberTop TrendingCardi BIPL AuctionShedeur SandersDrake MayeGold Price PredictionImran Khan ProtestWWE Raw HighlightsIND vs SA 2nd ODI TimeIPL Auction Players ListSmriti Mandhana
The Supreme Court on Tuesday took a sharp stance while hearing a habeas corpus plea alleging the custodial disappearance of Rohingya individuals and seeking that any deportation follow due process, asking whether “intruders” should be given a “red carpet welcome,” as reported by LiveLaw.Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, sitting with Justice Joymalya Bagchi, questioned the basis of the plea, asking, “Where is the order of the Government of India declaring them (Rohingyas) as refugees? Refugee is a well defined legal term… If there is no legal status of a refugee, and somebody is an intruder, and he enters illegally, do we have an obligation to keep that fellow here?”The petitioner’s counsel clarified that no refugee status was being sought — only that deportation must follow law.LiveLaw quoted the bench saying: “If they don’t have legal status to stay in India… If an intruder comes, do we give them a red carpet welcome saying we would like to give you all facilities? What is the problem in sending them back?”CJI Kant further remarked on illegal entry, saying: “First you enter, you cross the border illegally… Then you say, now that I have entered, your laws must apply to me… Do we want to stretch the law like this?”
