Nagpur consumer panel holds NHAI liable for pothole damage A consumer commission in Maharashtra’s Nagpur has held that collecting toll fees without ensuring well-maintained roads amounts to a “deficiency in service”. It directed the National Highways Authority of India to compensate a motorist whose vehicle was damaged after hitting potholes, as cited by PTI.In an order passed earlier this month, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Nagpur, said that “providing a safe and motorable road by charging toll fees is the responsibility of the toll collecting company/authority.””Collecting toll and providing a bad road is a deficiency in service,” it added.According to the complaint, the motorist was travelling from Nagpur in Maharashtra to Chhindwara in Madhya Pradesh on October 2, 2020, after paying the prescribed toll fee, when his car hit a deep pothole on the highway. He alleged that the impact severely damaged the vehicle’s steel wheel rim and dislodged the tyre.The complainant said he completed the remainder of the journey using the spare tyre and had to extend his stay by a day to get the vehicle repaired.He further alleged that toll plaza staff refused to provide a complaint register on his return journey, claiming that the official in charge was unavailable. Although he later served a notice on the highway authorities seeking reimbursement of the repair expenses, he claimed no action was taken.Subsequently, he approached the consumer commission, alleging deficiency in service by NHAI and seeking compensation for the losses incurred.In its written submission, the NHAI’s Chhindwara unit acknowledged the presence of potholes on the road, attributing them to heavy rainfall and high traffic volume, and said repair work was under way at the time of the incident.While expressing regret over the inconvenience caused to the complainant, the authority urged the commission to dismiss the case, contending that the motorist had failed to produce evidence showing the vehicle had been regularly maintained.Rejecting the NHAI’s defence, the commission held that a consumer is not required under the Consumer Protection Act to produce records of regular vehicle maintenance. It said establishing that the damage was directly caused by the potholes was sufficient to sustain the complaint.Since the main responsibility of toll collection and road maintenance is of Opposite Party 2 (NHAI Chhindwara project unit), the responsibility for compensation is fixed on them,” the commission ruled.”It is the responsibility of Opposite Party 2 to provide a safe and well-maintained road by charging a toll fee. Therefore, it is our opinion that if the vehicle is damaged due to the bad condition of the road, it is a deficiency in service,” it added.The commission directed the unit to pay the complainant Rs 1,030 towards vehicle repair and toll reimbursement, Rs 10,000 as compensation for mental and physical distress, and Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs.The commission directed the NHAI to pay the compensation within 45 days.Get the latest India news and live updates. Download the TOI App.About the AuthorTOI News DeskThe TOI News Desk comprises a dedicated and tireless team of journalists who operate around the clock to deliver the most current and comprehensive news and updates to the readers of The Times of India worldwide. With an unwavering commitment to excellence in journalism, our team is at the forefront of gathering, verifying, and presenting breaking news, in-depth analysis, and insightful reports on a wide range of topics. The TOI News Desk is your trusted source for staying informed and connected to the ever-evolving global landscape, ensuring that our readers are equipped with the latest developments that matter most.”Read MoreEnd of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosSonam Wangchuk Begins Indefinite Fast, Urges Nation To Join Education Reform MovementBengal BJP Govt Rolls Back OBC Quota Hike, Scraps 113 Groups Added Under TMCPM Modi To Skip Khamenei Funeral; Bihar Governor, MoS External Affairs To Represent India: Report’In 3 Or 6 Months’: Stalin Predicts Early Polls, Says Vijay-led TVK Govt May Not Last Full TermExplained: Why The Akal Takht Has Summoned 87 Sikh Legislators Over Punjab’s Anti-Sacrilege LawIndia’s First Integrated Battle Groups Explained: A New Era of Border Readiness32 Years After the Pact, Rajasthan Finally Set to Get Yamuna Water from HaryanaPM Modi’s Seychelles Visit: Why This Tiny Island Is Key to India’s Battle for the Indian OceanMumbai Muharram Poison Plot: Why Police Are Investigating the Iran-Iraq Angle?Nah Tribal Body Claims PLA Occupied Ancestral Land, China Built Roads and Camps in Arunachal Pradesh123PhotostoriesPsychology says people who don’t have many close friends may be more selective in love, and that’s not always a bad thing10 timeless baby girl names inspired by courageous women warriors in history4 secrets the happiest couples you meet are hiding from youVande Bharat routes under ₹1,500: From Goa to Kerala, these budget trips are worth every rupeeTaylor Swift’s best white gowns, ahead of her wedding with Travis Kelce: From ‘Folklore’ to ‘The Fate of Ophelia’PM Narendra Modi says “Chutney and Samosa reflect the shared heritage of India and Seychelles”: 6 traditional dishes that prove itHow to care for antique kundan and polki jewellery: Expert tips to prevent tarnishingOTT releases this week (June 29-July 5): ‘Pritam and Pedro’, ‘Enola Holmes 3’, ‘Tavvai’, ‘Isakapatnam’ and more5 ways to fall in love with your life and feel alive again5 cutest fish in the ocean you’ll instantly love123Hot PicksIreland CoachKerala HSCAP third allotment listWeather tomorrowFIFA world cup 2026Ketan Agarwal murder caseMumbai monsoonFIFA World Cup Round of ScheduleUS Strike on IranVaibhav SooryavanshiTop TrendingRam Mandir Donation TheftSimone BilesNoida fireFIFA World Cup 2026CBSE Three language GuidelinesBengaluru TechieAnukalp MishraSergei IvanovMK StalinMumbai Local Train News
A consumer commission in Maharashtra’s Nagpur has held that collecting toll fees without ensuring well-maintained roads amounts to a “deficiency in service”. It directed the National Highways Authority of India to compensate a motorist whose vehicle was damaged after hitting potholes, as cited by PTI.In an order passed earlier this month, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Nagpur, said that “providing a safe and motorable road by charging toll fees is the responsibility of the toll collecting company/authority.”“Collecting toll and providing a bad road is a deficiency in service,” it added.According to the complaint, the motorist was travelling from Nagpur in Maharashtra to Chhindwara in Madhya Pradesh on October 2, 2020, after paying the prescribed toll fee, when his car hit a deep pothole on the highway. He alleged that the impact severely damaged the vehicle’s steel wheel rim and dislodged the tyre.The complainant said he completed the remainder of the journey using the spare tyre and had to extend his stay by a day to get the vehicle repaired.He further alleged that toll plaza staff refused to provide a complaint register on his return journey, claiming that the official in charge was unavailable. Although he later served a notice on the highway authorities seeking reimbursement of the repair expenses, he claimed no action was taken.Subsequently, he approached the consumer commission, alleging deficiency in service by NHAI and seeking compensation for the losses incurred.In its written submission, the NHAI’s Chhindwara unit acknowledged the presence of potholes on the road, attributing them to heavy rainfall and high traffic volume, and said repair work was under way at the time of the incident.While expressing regret over the inconvenience caused to the complainant, the authority urged the commission to dismiss the case, contending that the motorist had failed to produce evidence showing the vehicle had been regularly maintained.Rejecting the NHAI’s defence, the commission held that a consumer is not required under the Consumer Protection Act to produce records of regular vehicle maintenance. It said establishing that the damage was directly caused by the potholes was sufficient to sustain the complaint.Since the main responsibility of toll collection and road maintenance is of Opposite Party 2 (NHAI Chhindwara project unit), the responsibility for compensation is fixed on them,” the commission ruled.“It is the responsibility of Opposite Party 2 to provide a safe and well-maintained road by charging a toll fee. Therefore, it is our opinion that if the vehicle is damaged due to the bad condition of the road, it is a deficiency in service,” it added.The commission directed the unit to pay the complainant Rs 1,030 towards vehicle repair and toll reimbursement, Rs 10,000 as compensation for mental and physical distress, and Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs.The commission directed the NHAI to pay the compensation within 45 days.
