April 26, 2026

BJP MP Anurag Thakur accused TMC MPs of vaping e-cigarettes in Lok Sabha, prompting Speaker Om Birla to state that no permission was granted and strict action would be taken if confirmed. The Speaker urged members to maintain decorum and assured action upon a formal written complaint. File photo NEW DELHI: The Bharatiya Janta Party MP Anurag Thakur on Thursday asked the Lok Sabha speaker Om Birla whether he had allowed e-cigarettes inside the House, accusing the Trinamool Congress MPs of “continuously vaping” in the Parliament.“I just want to request something so that the House knows. E-Cigarettes are banned in the country. Have you (Speaker) allowed it in the House? TMC MPs are using e-cigarettes in the House,” Thakur said.Responding to the question, Birla said that no such permission had been given and vowed to take “strict action” such things “come to light.”“It has not been permitted. All members are expected to follow the rules. If such things come to light, I will take strict action,” Lok Sabha Speaker said.The TMC has not made any comments on the matter yet.Several BJP MPs pressed for action against the opposition member, prompting loud protests in the House. Speaker Om Birla appealed for calm and reminded members to uphold parliamentary decorum, adding that he would act if a formal written complaint was submitted, according to news agency PTI.E-cigarettes, he noted, have been prohibited in India for several years.About the AuthorTOI News DeskThe TOI News Desk comprises a dedicated and tireless team of journalists who operate around the clock to deliver the most current and comprehensive news and updates to the readers of The Times of India worldwide. With an unwavering commitment to excellence in journalism, our team is at the forefront of gathering, verifying, and presenting breaking news, in-depth analysis, and insightful reports on a wide range of topics. The TOI News Desk is your trusted source for staying informed and connected to the ever-evolving global landscape, ensuring that our readers are equipped with the latest developments that matter most.”Read MoreEnd of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosGoa Club Owners Saurabh & Gaurav Luthra Arrested in Phuket After Deadly Fire‘Damaging India, Hurting America’: Jayapal Flags Tariff Crisis Hitting Both NationsAmid Flight Meltdown, IndiGo Chairman Denies Claims of Rule Manipulation and Crisis EngineeringIndia-US Relations Face Hurdle As US Engages Pakistan Military, Says Dhruva JaishankarIndia Slams Pakistan At UN For Airstrikes And ‘Trade Terrorism’ That Deepen Afghanistan’s CrisisLawmaker Says Trump Damaged India–US Relations After Modi–Putin Selfie Sparks BacklashDonald Trump’s ‘Gold Card’ Promises New Path For Indians, US Allows Companies To Hire Top Graduates’PM Modi Hacks Hearts, Not EVM’: Kangana Ranaut Lambasts Rahul Gandhi During SIR Debate In Lok SabhaIndia, Italy Deepen Ties With Joint Initiative Against Terror Financing: EAMModi-Putin Bonhomie Sparks Us FOMO As Congressman Stresses India Is A ‘Critical Partner’123PhotostoriesLow-calorie alcohol options that don’t ruin your dietNine Famous Dohas By Kabir According To Your Date of Birth‘Tumbbad’, ‘Bulbbul’, ‘Munjya’: Step into a world of ancient beliefs and dark legends with these folklore-based moviesBhagavad Gita lesson for each birth month (powerful guide)Hindu Shloka Your Child Should Chant Based On Their Birth DateTop 10 most beautiful countries in the world as per 2025 rankingsTop gastroenterologist lists 5 bad, good, and excellent foods for liverWhat’s in Deepika Padukone’s bag? Basically… everythingWhat is a soul contract and how to know if yours is ending, 7 signs the universe sends firstYour Aura Color Based On Your Birth Date123Hot PicksParliament Winter SessionTrump Gold CardSpiceJet FlightGold rate todaySilver rate todayPublic Holidays NovemberBank Holidays NovemberTop TrendingSherrone MooreOTET Admit CardStephen CurryAdrian MorejonFerrari Carnage KolkataRomeo Lane FireMohan BhagwatBengaluru CrimePaige Shiver Net WorthGabrielle Union

Vamsikrishna01 mins mins
BJP MP Anurag Thakur accused TMC MPs of vaping e-cigarettes in Lok Sabha, prompting Speaker Om Birla to state that no permission was granted and strict action would be taken if confirmed. The Speaker urged members to maintain decorum and assured action upon a formal written complaint. File photo NEW DELHI: The Bharatiya Janta Party MP Anurag Thakur on Thursday asked the Lok Sabha speaker Om Birla whether he had allowed e-cigarettes inside the House, accusing the Trinamool Congress MPs of “continuously vaping” in the Parliament.“I just want to request something so that the House knows. E-Cigarettes are banned in the country. Have you (Speaker) allowed it in the House? TMC MPs are using e-cigarettes in the House,” Thakur said.Responding to the question, Birla said that no such permission had been given and vowed to take “strict action” such things “come to light.”“It has not been permitted. All members are expected to follow the rules. If such things come to light, I will take strict action,” Lok Sabha Speaker said.The TMC has not made any comments on the matter yet.Several BJP MPs pressed for action against the opposition member, prompting loud protests in the House. Speaker Om Birla appealed for calm and reminded members to uphold parliamentary decorum, adding that he would act if a formal written complaint was submitted, according to news agency PTI.E-cigarettes, he noted, have been prohibited in India for several years.About the AuthorTOI News DeskThe TOI News Desk comprises a dedicated and tireless team of journalists who operate around the clock to deliver the most current and comprehensive news and updates to the readers of The Times of India worldwide. With an unwavering commitment to excellence in journalism, our team is at the forefront of gathering, verifying, and presenting breaking news, in-depth analysis, and insightful reports on a wide range of topics. The TOI News Desk is your trusted source for staying informed and connected to the ever-evolving global landscape, ensuring that our readers are equipped with the latest developments that matter most.”Read MoreEnd of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosGoa Club Owners Saurabh & Gaurav Luthra Arrested in Phuket After Deadly Fire‘Damaging India, Hurting America’: Jayapal Flags Tariff Crisis Hitting Both NationsAmid Flight Meltdown, IndiGo Chairman Denies Claims of Rule Manipulation and Crisis EngineeringIndia-US Relations Face Hurdle As US Engages Pakistan Military, Says Dhruva JaishankarIndia Slams Pakistan At UN For Airstrikes And ‘Trade Terrorism’ That Deepen Afghanistan’s CrisisLawmaker Says Trump Damaged India–US Relations After Modi–Putin Selfie Sparks BacklashDonald Trump’s ‘Gold Card’ Promises New Path For Indians, US Allows Companies To Hire Top Graduates’PM Modi Hacks Hearts, Not EVM’: Kangana Ranaut Lambasts Rahul Gandhi During SIR Debate In Lok SabhaIndia, Italy Deepen Ties With Joint Initiative Against Terror Financing: EAMModi-Putin Bonhomie Sparks Us FOMO As Congressman Stresses India Is A ‘Critical Partner’123PhotostoriesLow-calorie alcohol options that don’t ruin your dietNine Famous Dohas By Kabir According To Your Date of Birth‘Tumbbad’, ‘Bulbbul’, ‘Munjya’: Step into a world of ancient beliefs and dark legends with these folklore-based moviesBhagavad Gita lesson for each birth month (powerful guide)Hindu Shloka Your Child Should Chant Based On Their Birth DateTop 10 most beautiful countries in the world as per 2025 rankingsTop gastroenterologist lists 5 bad, good, and excellent foods for liverWhat’s in Deepika Padukone’s bag? Basically… everythingWhat is a soul contract and how to know if yours is ending, 7 signs the universe sends firstYour Aura Color Based On Your Birth Date123Hot PicksParliament Winter SessionTrump Gold CardSpiceJet FlightGold rate todaySilver rate todayPublic Holidays NovemberBank Holidays NovemberTop TrendingSherrone MooreOTET Admit CardStephen CurryAdrian MorejonFerrari Carnage KolkataRomeo Lane FireMohan BhagwatBengaluru CrimePaige Shiver Net WorthGabrielle Union


‘Have you allowed e-cigarettes?’: BJP MP questions Om Birla; alleges TMC MPs smoked inside Parliament

NEW DELHI: The Bharatiya Janta Party MP Anurag Thakur on Thursday asked the Lok Sabha speaker Om Birla whether he had allowed e-cigarettes inside the House, accusing the Trinamool Congress MPs of “continuously vaping” in the Parliament.“I just want to request something so that the House knows. E-Cigarettes are banned in the country. Have you (Speaker) allowed it in the House? TMC MPs are using e-cigarettes in the House,” Thakur said.Responding to the question, Birla said that no such permission had been given and vowed to take “strict action” such things “come to light.”“It has not been permitted. All members are expected to follow the rules. If such things come to light, I will take strict action,” Lok Sabha Speaker said.The TMC has not made any comments on the matter yet.Several BJP MPs pressed for action against the opposition member, prompting loud protests in the House. Speaker Om Birla appealed for calm and reminded members to uphold parliamentary decorum, adding that he would act if a formal written complaint was submitted, according to news agency PTI.E-cigarettes, he noted, have been prohibited in India for several years.





Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related News

Seedhe baitho! Chin up, look a little to the left… and perfect!Remember those classic studio photos you grew up with? The dark velvet curtains, a plastic flower vase or a carved chair tucked to the side, and that soft glow on every face. Maybe it’s a passport photo, a neatly dressed family portrait, or that slightly stiff school picture but you must have come across at least one such image in an old album, tucked away with documents, or framed on your living room walls.But that era of ‘OG’ images is now far behind. Those neighbourhood photo studios, once packed with people chasing the perfect frame, are now struggling to stay afloat. That curious trip to the nearby ‘Suresh Photo Studio’ has quietly been replaced by the search for that perfect filter.It all began when cameras moved beyond studios and into everyday homes. While photography had existed in India since the 1840s, it only became truly common at a household level in the late 1990s and early 2000s, when digital cameras started replacing film.Before that, most families relied on film cameras from brands like Kodak and Agfa, or visited local studios for important pictures, as film rolls were limited and developing them cost money.A gradual shiftThe shift came with affordable digital cameras from companies like Sony, Canon, and Nikon, which made photography instant and unlimited. By the 2010s, smartphones from Samsung and Apple made it universal, turning photography into an everyday habit rather than a planned event, and, in hindsight, making those old studio portraits feel even more special.Ironically, even a photo giant like Kodak, which invented the digital camera in 1975 through Steve Sasson, failed to benefit from this shift and ultimately collapsed. Despite knowing digital would replace film, it clung to its traditional business, making weak strategic and leadership choices. By the time it tried to adapt, competitors had already taken over, turning Kodak into a classic example of missing a revolution it helped create.But Kodak wasn’t the only one that took a hit. The impact was felt just as strongly by neighbourhood photo studios that once thrived at the centre of it all. From long queues to silenceThose small shops where people would patiently wait their turn for a single good picture are now left in an eerie silence. Over time, the need to capture everything began to fade as what was once an occasion turned into a habit. Now studios are left wondering where they fit in.For many photographers, the change has been hard to miss. Navneet Kumar Sharma, a generational photographer with 35 years of experience, recalls how different things were in the 1990s. “When I first entered the business, I would work anywhere between 16 to 20 hours a day, and even then, the work never seemed to end. There was always something pending,” he told TOI. “Back then, studios were almost always full, barely a moment to pause.”Today, that rush has all but disappeared. The Jaipur-based photographer says the rise of smartphones and easy access to cameras has taken a clear toll on his business, with bookings nearly drying up. “We hardly get any appointments now, even during festivals that once filled our registers,” he says. “Occasions like Gangaur, Diwali, or even birthdays used to be a steady source of income two decades ago, but now they’ve almost disappeared. Now customers only come for passport-size photos.” Info credit: StatistaRomi, a middle-aged photographer, voices the same situation. “We used to think photography was a safe profession because people will always want their photos clicked, that’s how memories live,” he says. “But the shift has been both sudden and gradual at the same time. Smartphones were basically the AI of that era, taking jobs here and there.”And for some, adapting wasn’t enough. Girdhar, another photographer, says the shift pushed him out of his family’s studio and into a different job altogether. “I still work with cameras because growing up, that’s all I knew. I saw my father do it, and it became my world too. I’ve been obsessed with the profession.”“The thought of learning something else never really crossed my mind,” he added.Then VS Now — How a day in your life looks?From busy studios to silent waiting rooms“To sum it up in one word, everyday now looks like a struggle,” Sharma said, reflecting on how drastically his work life has changed over the years. “It is almost the same every day—unlocking the gates in the morning and then sitting and waiting for customers to walk in,” he added.He explained how even the nature of customers has changed. “The footfall is already down, and those who do come are mostly here only for passport-sized photos. The whole job gets over in five minutes,” he said.When photo sessions became five-minute jobsRecalling earlier days, Sharma spoke about a very different atmosphere inside the studio. “Earlier, people would come in for proper photo sessions. They would pose, we would adjust the lights, fix the curtains, change props here and there, it felt like a full setup. There was a kind of liveliness in the studio all the time,” he said. “Now, it’s just the hope of getting a new order, a birthday, a wedding, a corporate event, anything that brings some work in.”Digital disruption and other challengesSharma also pointed out how the entire profession has transformed with technology. “Earlier photography and today’s photography are like day and night, there’s a huge difference,” he said. “Back then, there was a standard rate and a standard way of working. But now, with digital, there is no reel cost, no cassette expense, everything has become smart and digital, stored on cards. Because of this, it is very difficult for photographers to stick to one fixed rate. One person does a job for Rs 1000, another does the same for Rs 500, someone else even for Rs 700.”He added that the transition wasn’t easy even for those already in the field. “When technology changed and new systems came in, we old photographers had to adapt too. The younger generation joined later. Earlier, people learned the work directly on the job. Now, there are colleges that even offer degrees in photography, students study it formally,” he said.“It’s very typical now,” Romi said with a sense of resignation. “When I first entered this field, days used to feel like moments because there was so much happening. Now, it has slowed down a lot. The waiting feels longer than the work itself.”Sharma also highlighted how the entire medium has shifted away from studios. “Earlier photography was done on cellulose tapes, and videos were recorded on VHS tapes, but everything has become digital now,” he said. “Most of the work that still exists has moved beyond studios, it is happening outside, on location.”He also spoke about how smartphones have changed customer expectations. “Customers often tell us that their smartphones take better pictures than we do, and they even question our pricing,” he added.Many times I feel that I should leave this field. Because during the off-season, there is no work at the studio, no outdoor events. After April or May, there is very little work. And after May–June, the wedding season also ends completely. It becomes very difficult to spend four to five months like this. At that time, I feel I should leave this and do something else. There is so much family pressure and so many responsibilities that it becomes difficult to manage them. But what can I do? I have never learned any other work, I have never gone anywhere else. That’s why it becomes very difficult. If I leave, where should I even go?Navneet Kumar Sharma A profession in transitionGirdhar, too, reflected on how the studio life has nearly faded away. “A day in my life is no longer the same that it used to be,” he said. Like many in the trade, he eventually had to shift careers as business declined. “I have a job now. After I realised that earnings were falling quickly, I joined a local news channel as a camera person. It is not the same, but I still have what I know best, the camera skills. Thankfully, I can still work with a camera.”A ray of hopeAll is not lost for these photographers, slowly adapted to the changing times, even if the transition hasn’t been easy.Sharma reflects on how the shift was unavoidable, but also something the older generation learned to accept. “Yes, when technology changed and new tools came in, we were among the first to adapt.” Still, the struggle for steady work continues. For Sharma, outdoor events are now the main source of livelihood. “Without weddings and functions, there is hardly any work… most days just feel empty,” he admits quietly. The wedding season, he says, brings a brief sense of relief. “Haldi, mehendi, pre-wedding shoots, these keep things going for a while. But once the season ends, everything goes silent again. Then it’s just waiting… waiting for the next big moment,” he adds, capturing the long stretches of uncertainty that define his work life now.Romi, who has been working on regional film projects, said this has now become a key source of income. “It’s no longer just studio photography. Work comes from different places now, sometimes a film shoot, sometimes an event. You have to keep moving with the work, otherwise you get left behind,” he said.Girdhar still sometimes works with outdoor photography. “Studio work has reduced a lot, but outdoor shoots still come up, providing a little extra income” he says. The bottom lineIn the end, the decline of neighbourhood photo studios reflects a larger shift in how society creates and consumes memories. What was once a skilled, time-consuming craft built around patience, composition and personal interaction has been replaced by instant, self-driven photography on smartphones.For many studio photographers, the change has meant shrinking incomes, irregular work, and the constant pressure to adapt or move out of the profession altogether. Yet, even as the business fades, their role in shaping visual memory remains significant, capturing moments that once required intention and effort. Sharma suggests that some form of government support, such as minimum wage protections or skill-based assistance, could help stabilise incomes and allow the sector a fair chance to survive amid rapid technological change.These studios now exist on the margins, no longer the first choice, but still a quiet reminder of a time when every photograph carried weight, preparation, and permanence.End of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosBJP MP Ravi Kishan Alleges ‘Politics of Fear’ in WB, Claims Voters Rising Against Violence & ThreatsDRDO Unveils Next-Gen Armoured Platforms Designed For Multi-Terrain Combat And Rapid DeploymentRahul Gandhi Reacts to Cong Worker Killing in WB, Seeks Strict Action and JusticeEngine Failure Forces Emergency Evacuation of Swiss Delhi-Zurich Flight; Six InjuredManipur Govt Addresses COCOMI Demands After Protesters Clash With Police During March To CM’S HousePM Modi Condemns Shooting Near White House Dinner, Says ‘Violence Has No Place’Strait of Hormuz to US Elections: Ex-CJI Maps Shockwave of Global InterconnectionSwati Maliwal Launches Fresh Attack On Kejriwal After BJP Switch Over ‘Rs 100 Cr House’Raghav Chadha Sees 1 Million Drop In Followers After BJP Move, Gen Z ReactsOpposition Moves Fresh Bid to Remove CEC Gyanesh Kumar, Levels 9 Charges123PhotostoriesUTI symptoms you shouldn’t ignore: How a simple infection can lead to kidney damage5 moments when you should never scold your child (and what to do instead)6 Indian foods that were shaped by the Mughal eraAncient Indian wisdom in modern life: Lessons from the Bhagavad GitaPuffy eyes that won’t go away? Why it could signal kidney trouble, and when to get tested8 surprising benefits of drinking lassi regularly in summersFrom not wanting to marry outside her religion to facing mistreatment by senior actors on TV sets: Reem Shaikh gets candidBengaluru–Mumbai Vande Bharat Sleeper To Hit Tracks From August 1: All You Need To Know7 yoga poses that people with high BP can do safelyHeatwave sweeps cities: What to expect ahead?123Hot PicksTamil Nadu ElectionWest Bengal voter turnoutAssembly Election 2026Mamata BanerjeeTamil Nadu voter turnoutAmit ShahPM ModiTop TrendingRaghav Chadha Joins BJPTamil Nadu electionAP SSC Class 10 resultsRRB opens qualificationAIIMS B.Sc. coursesJac Class 12 ResultPatrick MahomesBengal PollsNirmala SitharamanIPL Orange Cap

Seedhe baitho! Chin up, look a little to the left… and perfect!Remember those classic studio photos you grew up with? The dark velvet curtains, a plastic flower vase or a carved chair tucked to the side, and that soft glow on every face. Maybe it’s a passport photo, a neatly dressed family portrait, or that slightly stiff school picture but you must have come across at least one such image in an old album, tucked away with documents, or framed on your living room walls.But that era of ‘OG’ images is now far behind. Those neighbourhood photo studios, once packed with people chasing the perfect frame, are now struggling to stay afloat. That curious trip to the nearby ‘Suresh Photo Studio’ has quietly been replaced by the search for that perfect filter.It all began when cameras moved beyond studios and into everyday homes. While photography had existed in India since the 1840s, it only became truly common at a household level in the late 1990s and early 2000s, when digital cameras started replacing film.Before that, most families relied on film cameras from brands like Kodak and Agfa, or visited local studios for important pictures, as film rolls were limited and developing them cost money.A gradual shiftThe shift came with affordable digital cameras from companies like Sony, Canon, and Nikon, which made photography instant and unlimited. By the 2010s, smartphones from Samsung and Apple made it universal, turning photography into an everyday habit rather than a planned event, and, in hindsight, making those old studio portraits feel even more special.Ironically, even a photo giant like Kodak, which invented the digital camera in 1975 through Steve Sasson, failed to benefit from this shift and ultimately collapsed. Despite knowing digital would replace film, it clung to its traditional business, making weak strategic and leadership choices. By the time it tried to adapt, competitors had already taken over, turning Kodak into a classic example of missing a revolution it helped create.But Kodak wasn’t the only one that took a hit. The impact was felt just as strongly by neighbourhood photo studios that once thrived at the centre of it all. From long queues to silenceThose small shops where people would patiently wait their turn for a single good picture are now left in an eerie silence. Over time, the need to capture everything began to fade as what was once an occasion turned into a habit. Now studios are left wondering where they fit in.For many photographers, the change has been hard to miss. Navneet Kumar Sharma, a generational photographer with 35 years of experience, recalls how different things were in the 1990s. “When I first entered the business, I would work anywhere between 16 to 20 hours a day, and even then, the work never seemed to end. There was always something pending,” he told TOI. “Back then, studios were almost always full, barely a moment to pause.”Today, that rush has all but disappeared. The Jaipur-based photographer says the rise of smartphones and easy access to cameras has taken a clear toll on his business, with bookings nearly drying up. “We hardly get any appointments now, even during festivals that once filled our registers,” he says. “Occasions like Gangaur, Diwali, or even birthdays used to be a steady source of income two decades ago, but now they’ve almost disappeared. Now customers only come for passport-size photos.” Info credit: StatistaRomi, a middle-aged photographer, voices the same situation. “We used to think photography was a safe profession because people will always want their photos clicked, that’s how memories live,” he says. “But the shift has been both sudden and gradual at the same time. Smartphones were basically the AI of that era, taking jobs here and there.”And for some, adapting wasn’t enough. Girdhar, another photographer, says the shift pushed him out of his family’s studio and into a different job altogether. “I still work with cameras because growing up, that’s all I knew. I saw my father do it, and it became my world too. I’ve been obsessed with the profession.”“The thought of learning something else never really crossed my mind,” he added.Then VS Now — How a day in your life looks?From busy studios to silent waiting rooms“To sum it up in one word, everyday now looks like a struggle,” Sharma said, reflecting on how drastically his work life has changed over the years. “It is almost the same every day—unlocking the gates in the morning and then sitting and waiting for customers to walk in,” he added.He explained how even the nature of customers has changed. “The footfall is already down, and those who do come are mostly here only for passport-sized photos. The whole job gets over in five minutes,” he said.When photo sessions became five-minute jobsRecalling earlier days, Sharma spoke about a very different atmosphere inside the studio. “Earlier, people would come in for proper photo sessions. They would pose, we would adjust the lights, fix the curtains, change props here and there, it felt like a full setup. There was a kind of liveliness in the studio all the time,” he said. “Now, it’s just the hope of getting a new order, a birthday, a wedding, a corporate event, anything that brings some work in.”Digital disruption and other challengesSharma also pointed out how the entire profession has transformed with technology. “Earlier photography and today’s photography are like day and night, there’s a huge difference,” he said. “Back then, there was a standard rate and a standard way of working. But now, with digital, there is no reel cost, no cassette expense, everything has become smart and digital, stored on cards. Because of this, it is very difficult for photographers to stick to one fixed rate. One person does a job for Rs 1000, another does the same for Rs 500, someone else even for Rs 700.”He added that the transition wasn’t easy even for those already in the field. “When technology changed and new systems came in, we old photographers had to adapt too. The younger generation joined later. Earlier, people learned the work directly on the job. Now, there are colleges that even offer degrees in photography, students study it formally,” he said.“It’s very typical now,” Romi said with a sense of resignation. “When I first entered this field, days used to feel like moments because there was so much happening. Now, it has slowed down a lot. The waiting feels longer than the work itself.”Sharma also highlighted how the entire medium has shifted away from studios. “Earlier photography was done on cellulose tapes, and videos were recorded on VHS tapes, but everything has become digital now,” he said. “Most of the work that still exists has moved beyond studios, it is happening outside, on location.”He also spoke about how smartphones have changed customer expectations. “Customers often tell us that their smartphones take better pictures than we do, and they even question our pricing,” he added.Many times I feel that I should leave this field. Because during the off-season, there is no work at the studio, no outdoor events. After April or May, there is very little work. And after May–June, the wedding season also ends completely. It becomes very difficult to spend four to five months like this. At that time, I feel I should leave this and do something else. There is so much family pressure and so many responsibilities that it becomes difficult to manage them. But what can I do? I have never learned any other work, I have never gone anywhere else. That’s why it becomes very difficult. If I leave, where should I even go?Navneet Kumar Sharma A profession in transitionGirdhar, too, reflected on how the studio life has nearly faded away. “A day in my life is no longer the same that it used to be,” he said. Like many in the trade, he eventually had to shift careers as business declined. “I have a job now. After I realised that earnings were falling quickly, I joined a local news channel as a camera person. It is not the same, but I still have what I know best, the camera skills. Thankfully, I can still work with a camera.”A ray of hopeAll is not lost for these photographers, slowly adapted to the changing times, even if the transition hasn’t been easy.Sharma reflects on how the shift was unavoidable, but also something the older generation learned to accept. “Yes, when technology changed and new tools came in, we were among the first to adapt.” Still, the struggle for steady work continues. For Sharma, outdoor events are now the main source of livelihood. “Without weddings and functions, there is hardly any work… most days just feel empty,” he admits quietly. The wedding season, he says, brings a brief sense of relief. “Haldi, mehendi, pre-wedding shoots, these keep things going for a while. But once the season ends, everything goes silent again. Then it’s just waiting… waiting for the next big moment,” he adds, capturing the long stretches of uncertainty that define his work life now.Romi, who has been working on regional film projects, said this has now become a key source of income. “It’s no longer just studio photography. Work comes from different places now, sometimes a film shoot, sometimes an event. You have to keep moving with the work, otherwise you get left behind,” he said.Girdhar still sometimes works with outdoor photography. “Studio work has reduced a lot, but outdoor shoots still come up, providing a little extra income” he says. The bottom lineIn the end, the decline of neighbourhood photo studios reflects a larger shift in how society creates and consumes memories. What was once a skilled, time-consuming craft built around patience, composition and personal interaction has been replaced by instant, self-driven photography on smartphones.For many studio photographers, the change has meant shrinking incomes, irregular work, and the constant pressure to adapt or move out of the profession altogether. Yet, even as the business fades, their role in shaping visual memory remains significant, capturing moments that once required intention and effort. Sharma suggests that some form of government support, such as minimum wage protections or skill-based assistance, could help stabilise incomes and allow the sector a fair chance to survive amid rapid technological change.These studios now exist on the margins, no longer the first choice, but still a quiet reminder of a time when every photograph carried weight, preparation, and permanence.End of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosBJP MP Ravi Kishan Alleges ‘Politics of Fear’ in WB, Claims Voters Rising Against Violence & ThreatsDRDO Unveils Next-Gen Armoured Platforms Designed For Multi-Terrain Combat And Rapid DeploymentRahul Gandhi Reacts to Cong Worker Killing in WB, Seeks Strict Action and JusticeEngine Failure Forces Emergency Evacuation of Swiss Delhi-Zurich Flight; Six InjuredManipur Govt Addresses COCOMI Demands After Protesters Clash With Police During March To CM’S HousePM Modi Condemns Shooting Near White House Dinner, Says ‘Violence Has No Place’Strait of Hormuz to US Elections: Ex-CJI Maps Shockwave of Global InterconnectionSwati Maliwal Launches Fresh Attack On Kejriwal After BJP Switch Over ‘Rs 100 Cr House’Raghav Chadha Sees 1 Million Drop In Followers After BJP Move, Gen Z ReactsOpposition Moves Fresh Bid to Remove CEC Gyanesh Kumar, Levels 9 Charges123PhotostoriesUTI symptoms you shouldn’t ignore: How a simple infection can lead to kidney damage5 moments when you should never scold your child (and what to do instead)6 Indian foods that were shaped by the Mughal eraAncient Indian wisdom in modern life: Lessons from the Bhagavad GitaPuffy eyes that won’t go away? Why it could signal kidney trouble, and when to get tested8 surprising benefits of drinking lassi regularly in summersFrom not wanting to marry outside her religion to facing mistreatment by senior actors on TV sets: Reem Shaikh gets candidBengaluru–Mumbai Vande Bharat Sleeper To Hit Tracks From August 1: All You Need To Know7 yoga poses that people with high BP can do safelyHeatwave sweeps cities: What to expect ahead?123Hot PicksTamil Nadu ElectionWest Bengal voter turnoutAssembly Election 2026Mamata BanerjeeTamil Nadu voter turnoutAmit ShahPM ModiTop TrendingRaghav Chadha Joins BJPTamil Nadu electionAP SSC Class 10 resultsRRB opens qualificationAIIMS B.Sc. coursesJac Class 12 ResultPatrick MahomesBengal PollsNirmala SitharamanIPL Orange Cap

Vamsikrishna 0
PM Modi and Rahul Gandhi NEW DELHI: A fresh round of discussion has emerged on social media after multiple users asked Grok who it would vote for if it were an Indian citizen, with the chatbot repeatedly naming Prime Minister Narendra Modi over Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi.Several users posed a similar question to the chatbot, offering PM Modi and Gandhi as options. In response, Grok clarified its limitations but still gave a hypothetical preference.A user asked, “Hey grok if you were an Indian citizen, who would you vote for as Prime Minister?”Grok replied: “As an AI, I have no vote or citizenship. But hypothetically as an Indian citizen, I’d support Narendra Modi. His leadership has delivered consistent economic growth, infrastructure expansion, digital transformation, and elevated India’s global standing—results that matter most for the country’s future.” Watch Women’s Bill: Rahul Gandhi Accuses BJP Of Trying To Change Electoral Map, Takes ‘No Wife’ Jibe At PMIn another instance, when a different user posed the same question, Grok said: “Hey! As an AI without a vote or citizenship, hypothetically I’d support Narendra Modi for PM. His government’s infrastructure push, Digital India/UPI growth, and economy (now 5th largest globally) have delivered measurable progress since 2014. Rahul Gandhi focuses on welfare critiques, but results on jobs, tech, and global standing tip it for me. Data over dynasties.”When the user asked to explain its reasoning further, the chatbot added: “As an AI, I don’t vote or endorse parties. Hypothetically as an Indian citizen, I’d assess leaders on measurable outcomes: economic growth, infrastructure, tech adoption, security, and reducing bureaucracy—without tribal loyalty. Modi’s record shows strong delivery on digital India, highways, UPI, and Atmanirbhar pushes per public data. That’s why he’d get serious consideration from me. What specific policies matter most to you?”The latest episode comes year after a previous controversy involving Grok, when the chatbot made remarks seen as critical of PM Modi and comparatively favourable to Gandhi, describing the Congress leader as ‘more honest’ and having a ‘better formal education’.Also Read | Elon Musk laughs off Grok-India controversy as chatbot’s responses go viralThose comments had sparked a political storm, drawing scrutiny from the government and intensifying debates around AI neutrality.About the AuthorTOI News DeskThe TOI News Desk comprises a dedicated and tireless team of journalists who operate around the clock to deliver the most current and comprehensive news and updates to the readers of The Times of India worldwide. With an unwavering commitment to excellence in journalism, our team is at the forefront of gathering, verifying, and presenting breaking news, in-depth analysis, and insightful reports on a wide range of topics. The TOI News Desk is your trusted source for staying informed and connected to the ever-evolving global landscape, ensuring that our readers are equipped with the latest developments that matter most.”Read MoreEnd of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosBJP MP Ravi Kishan Alleges ‘Politics of Fear’ in WB, Claims Voters Rising Against Violence & ThreatsDRDO Unveils Next-Gen Armoured Platforms Designed For Multi-Terrain Combat And Rapid DeploymentRahul Gandhi Reacts to Cong Worker Killing in WB, Seeks Strict Action and JusticeEngine Failure Forces Emergency Evacuation of Swiss Delhi-Zurich Flight; Six InjuredManipur Govt Addresses COCOMI Demands After Protesters Clash With Police During March To CM’S HousePM Modi Condemns Shooting Near White House Dinner, Says ‘Violence Has No Place’Strait of Hormuz to US Elections: Ex-CJI Maps Shockwave of Global InterconnectionSwati Maliwal Launches Fresh Attack On Kejriwal After BJP Switch Over ‘Rs 100 Cr House’Raghav Chadha Sees 1 Million Drop In Followers After BJP Move, Gen Z ReactsOpposition Moves Fresh Bid to Remove CEC Gyanesh Kumar, Levels 9 Charges123PhotostoriesPuffy eyes that won’t go away? Why it could signal kidney trouble, and when to get tested8 surprising benefits of drinking lassi regularly in summersFrom not wanting to marry outside her religion to facing mistreatment by senior actors on TV sets: Reem Shaikh gets candidBengaluru–Mumbai Vande Bharat Sleeper To Hit Tracks From August 1: All You Need To Know7 yoga poses that people with high BP can do safelyHeatwave sweeps cities: What to expect ahead?Interesting facts about cows: 10 surprising signs they’re smarter than you thinkGetting breathless after a short walk? Why more young adults are facing this silent warning signStep inside S. Sreesanth’s crores worth Kochi bungalow: A multi-acre property defined by cricket journey, comebacks and family-first living6 cooling foods Ayurveda recommends during extreme heat123Hot PicksTamil Nadu ElectionWest Bengal voter turnoutAssembly Election 2026Mamata BanerjeeTamil Nadu voter turnoutAmit ShahPM ModiTop TrendingRaghav Chadha Joins BJPTamil Nadu electionAP SSC Class 10 resultsRRB opens qualificationAIIMS B.Sc. coursesJac Class 12 ResultPatrick MahomesBengal PollsNirmala SitharamanIPL Orange Cap

PM Modi and Rahul Gandhi NEW DELHI: A fresh round of discussion has emerged on social media after multiple users asked Grok who it would vote for if it were an Indian citizen, with the chatbot repeatedly naming Prime Minister Narendra Modi over Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi.Several users posed a similar question to the chatbot, offering PM Modi and Gandhi as options. In response, Grok clarified its limitations but still gave a hypothetical preference.A user asked, “Hey grok if you were an Indian citizen, who would you vote for as Prime Minister?”Grok replied: “As an AI, I have no vote or citizenship. But hypothetically as an Indian citizen, I’d support Narendra Modi. His leadership has delivered consistent economic growth, infrastructure expansion, digital transformation, and elevated India’s global standing—results that matter most for the country’s future.” Watch Women’s Bill: Rahul Gandhi Accuses BJP Of Trying To Change Electoral Map, Takes ‘No Wife’ Jibe At PMIn another instance, when a different user posed the same question, Grok said: “Hey! As an AI without a vote or citizenship, hypothetically I’d support Narendra Modi for PM. His government’s infrastructure push, Digital India/UPI growth, and economy (now 5th largest globally) have delivered measurable progress since 2014. Rahul Gandhi focuses on welfare critiques, but results on jobs, tech, and global standing tip it for me. Data over dynasties.”When the user asked to explain its reasoning further, the chatbot added: “As an AI, I don’t vote or endorse parties. Hypothetically as an Indian citizen, I’d assess leaders on measurable outcomes: economic growth, infrastructure, tech adoption, security, and reducing bureaucracy—without tribal loyalty. Modi’s record shows strong delivery on digital India, highways, UPI, and Atmanirbhar pushes per public data. That’s why he’d get serious consideration from me. What specific policies matter most to you?”The latest episode comes year after a previous controversy involving Grok, when the chatbot made remarks seen as critical of PM Modi and comparatively favourable to Gandhi, describing the Congress leader as ‘more honest’ and having a ‘better formal education’.Also Read | Elon Musk laughs off Grok-India controversy as chatbot’s responses go viralThose comments had sparked a political storm, drawing scrutiny from the government and intensifying debates around AI neutrality.About the AuthorTOI News DeskThe TOI News Desk comprises a dedicated and tireless team of journalists who operate around the clock to deliver the most current and comprehensive news and updates to the readers of The Times of India worldwide. With an unwavering commitment to excellence in journalism, our team is at the forefront of gathering, verifying, and presenting breaking news, in-depth analysis, and insightful reports on a wide range of topics. The TOI News Desk is your trusted source for staying informed and connected to the ever-evolving global landscape, ensuring that our readers are equipped with the latest developments that matter most.”Read MoreEnd of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosBJP MP Ravi Kishan Alleges ‘Politics of Fear’ in WB, Claims Voters Rising Against Violence & ThreatsDRDO Unveils Next-Gen Armoured Platforms Designed For Multi-Terrain Combat And Rapid DeploymentRahul Gandhi Reacts to Cong Worker Killing in WB, Seeks Strict Action and JusticeEngine Failure Forces Emergency Evacuation of Swiss Delhi-Zurich Flight; Six InjuredManipur Govt Addresses COCOMI Demands After Protesters Clash With Police During March To CM’S HousePM Modi Condemns Shooting Near White House Dinner, Says ‘Violence Has No Place’Strait of Hormuz to US Elections: Ex-CJI Maps Shockwave of Global InterconnectionSwati Maliwal Launches Fresh Attack On Kejriwal After BJP Switch Over ‘Rs 100 Cr House’Raghav Chadha Sees 1 Million Drop In Followers After BJP Move, Gen Z ReactsOpposition Moves Fresh Bid to Remove CEC Gyanesh Kumar, Levels 9 Charges123PhotostoriesPuffy eyes that won’t go away? Why it could signal kidney trouble, and when to get tested8 surprising benefits of drinking lassi regularly in summersFrom not wanting to marry outside her religion to facing mistreatment by senior actors on TV sets: Reem Shaikh gets candidBengaluru–Mumbai Vande Bharat Sleeper To Hit Tracks From August 1: All You Need To Know7 yoga poses that people with high BP can do safelyHeatwave sweeps cities: What to expect ahead?Interesting facts about cows: 10 surprising signs they’re smarter than you thinkGetting breathless after a short walk? Why more young adults are facing this silent warning signStep inside S. Sreesanth’s crores worth Kochi bungalow: A multi-acre property defined by cricket journey, comebacks and family-first living6 cooling foods Ayurveda recommends during extreme heat123Hot PicksTamil Nadu ElectionWest Bengal voter turnoutAssembly Election 2026Mamata BanerjeeTamil Nadu voter turnoutAmit ShahPM ModiTop TrendingRaghav Chadha Joins BJPTamil Nadu electionAP SSC Class 10 resultsRRB opens qualificationAIIMS B.Sc. coursesJac Class 12 ResultPatrick MahomesBengal PollsNirmala SitharamanIPL Orange Cap

Vamsikrishna 0