Amit Shah says ‘ready to sit through, take notes and respond to anything’ in Parliament. NEW DELHI: Union home minister Amit Shah on Wednesday offered to sit in Parliament from 3pm till 3pm the next day to hear the Opposition’s concerns and respond to every point, as the standoff over alleged police excesses against student protesters continued.Shah’s offer came amid Opposition protests demanding that he make a statement in Parliament on the alleged police action against students during their July 20 march over the NEET paper leak issue.Speaking to reporters, Shah rejected Opposition allegations that he had been absent from Parliament and said the government was ready for a detailed discussion on the issue.”First of all, terms like ‘laapata’, ‘bhaag gaye’ are the kind of language increasingly being heard in India’s public and parliamentary life. I have been coming to Parliament regularly since the session began; I sit in my chamber, but since the opposition is not allowing Parliament to function—in either House—what is one supposed to do?” Shah said.He said Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju had already made it clear that the government was ready for a full discussion on the student protests.”We asked for a time to be fixed and for the Opposition to be ready. That was their initial demand, and we agreed to it. I, too, have stated that I am ready to answer any question in Parliament, yet they simply do not want the discussion to take place,” Shah said.”Now, let the public decide who is running away. Let them submit a letter to the Speaker by 3:00 PM today. We are ready for a discussion on all aspects from 3:00 PM today until 3:00 PM tomorrow. I will sit in the House; I will listen to everyone and respond to every point. The government has nothing to hide,” he added.Shah said he was even willing to discuss why the Opposition had not allowed the debate to take place.”The NDA government—under Modi ji’s leadership is ready to discuss anything; they just need to let Parliament function,” he said.Elaborating on his offer, Shah said, “I want to tell the opposition: submit a letter to the Speaker by 2:00 PM, we will start the discussion at 3:00 PM, and I will provide answers to everything by 3:00 PM tomorrow.””There are established rules and procedures for parliamentary discussions. Yet, some ask me to simply make a statement. Such a serious issue cannot be discussed in that manner. That may be your method, but it is not the parliamentary way. In Parliament, discussions are held at length,” he said.”In Parliament, discussions are held at length. I am ready for the debate to continue from 3:00 PM today—sitting late into the night and continuing until 3:00 PM tomorrow; I am even prepared to suspend the Question Hour if the Speaker grants permission,” Shah said.”I am ready for the discussion to go on until 3:00 PM tomorrow. I will sit through it myself, take notes on everything, and respond to every point so that the entire matter becomes clear to the people of the country—so that the truth is fully revealed. Now, the Opposition must decide whether they want to engage in a discussion or create an uproar,” he added.Rahul Gandhi hits backLeader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi rejected Shah’s offer, saying the Opposition was seeking answers on the alleged police action against students rather than a lecture from the home minister.”The Opposition has clearly said that we are not interested in Amit Shah giving us a lecture. When I say ‘we’, I mean the younger generation of this country. Who shot the students? Who gave the order to beat up the students with lathis with nails? Did Amit Shah give this order to shoot our children? If he did, then he should resign. For the last 20 days, Amit Shah has been missing. The Home Minister of India has no courage; he cannot come to the House,” Rahul said.“Did Home Minister Shah give orders to shoot our children or not; if he did, he is culpable and if he did not, he is incompetent: Rahul Gandhi,” he added.The Opposition has been demanding Shah’s presence in Parliament and a statement on the alleged police excesses against students.Earlier in the day, Opposition MPs, including Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge and party general secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, staged a protest in the Parliament House Complex over the alleged theft of donations at the Ram temple in Ayodhya and the alleged police excesses against student protesters.Priyanka also questioned the government over the alleged use of force against students.”Who do you think is responsible for this? Are you (Home Minister Amit Shah) not answerable to the people when you lathi-charge students and use pellet guns against them, and use AK-47 on them in Bihar? Should we sit quietly like you all (the media)?” she said.The INDIA bloc has been protesting for more than three weeks, demanding Shah’s presence in the House and a statement from him.Government, Opposition remain at oddsThe government’s offer of a debate and Shah’s response failed to break the stalemate, with the Congress insisting that the home minister specifically address who ordered the alleged use of pellet guns against students.The Congress has also maintained that its demand for a discussion on the alleged theft of funds at the Ram temple is “non-negotiable”.Earlier on Monday, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju said the government was ready for a detailed discussion on the student protests and urged the Opposition not to disrupt proceedings when Shah responds.”The offer made by the government is very clear that it is ready to have a full and detailed discussion on students’ movement and activities related to it,” Rijiju said.”My only point made to the opposition is that while the discussion and a reply are being made, the opposition should not create disturbances to prevent the statement of the Home Minister,” he added. “They must listen to the reply of the home minister and the government. Join conversationView All Comments →Share your thoughts in the commentsInsightfulAgreeDisagreeSkepticalConcerningPromisingWorth ReadingBig DevelopmentPost CommentBe respectful · TOI community guidelinesOnce discussion begins, we must have a threadbare discussion.”Rijiju’s remarks came after Rahul Gandhi criticised the Centre over the alleged police action during the July 20 student protests at Jantar Mantar and demanded a court-monitored probe.Parliament proceedings have repeatedly been disrupted during the Monsoon Session, with several Bills passed by the Lok Sabha amid the continuing deadlock.Get the latest India News and Live updates. Download the TOI app.About the AuthorTOI News DeskThe TOI News Desk comprises a dedicated and tireless team of journalists who operate around the clock to deliver the most current and comprehensive news and updates to the readers of The Times of India worldwide. With an unwavering commitment to excellence in journalism, our team is at the forefront of gathering, verifying, and presenting breaking news, in-depth analysis, and insightful reports on a wide range of topics. The TOI News Desk is your trusted source for staying informed and connected to the ever-evolving global landscape, ensuring that our readers are equipped with the latest developments that matter most.”Read MoreEnd of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosExplained: Why Amritpal Singh’s Party Fielded Son of Indira Gandhi’s Assassin In Punjab Elections?Prashant Kishor Promises Jobs For 10,000 Bankipur Youths After Ending BJP’s 30-Year Hold | WatchIndia’s Map Move Rattles China: What Naming 27 Places In Arunachal Means?Air India Phuket-Delhi Pilot’s Confirmatory Dope Test Reportedly Positive For Marijuana, Sources SayTamil Nadu Assembly Passes Anti-NEET Resolution As DMK, AIADMK And PMK Back Abolition DemandDelhi CM Fumes, Rekha Gupta Slams AAP MLA Over Viral Video; Eight AAP MLAs Marshalled OutKashmiri Pandit Employees Sent On Leave After Lashkar-Linked Threat Letter‘Amit Shah Jawab Do’ Vs ‘Rahul Gandhi Bhaago Mat’: NDA, Oppn Face-Off In Parliament’Booked Hotel Room, Strangled Daughters’: Inside Bengaluru Murder Shocker‘Ladakh Is Not Kaziranga’: Snow Leopard Safari Plan Sparks Debate123Photostories9 of the most expensive ingredients grown in India6 common mistakes to avoid with pakodas and how to make them crispierFrom Mumbai to Chennai: Indian cities that were renamed and why10 baby names that represent the power and might of Lord ShivaUK Heatwave 2026: Met Office predicts this summer to be the hottest ever; 10 cities and urban areas under extreme heat stressWhy does your food taste bland? 4 common cooking mistakes to fixBaasi roti is an excellent breakfast: 5 health benefits you probably didn’t know about5 life lessons by Swami Vivekanand every student must knowRed pigments to elaborate hair: Japan’s longest-ruling dynasty, the Yamato Era’s beauty secrets decodedWhere is Westeros in real? 9 places ‘House of the Dragon’ built its realm in123Hot PicksInternational Youth DayMHT-CET CAP round seat allotmentSlovenia Indian embassyJharkhand protestN ChandrasekaranNEET PG 2026 city slipIran warSBI Clerk RecruitmentUP scholarshipTop TrendingChennai AirportNagpur Rape CaseAir India Phuket-Delhi FlightMumbai Kurla LandslideBengaluru Missing TechieSpiceJet FlightTelangana AccidentAbhijeet DipkeWeather TomorrowShakeel Noorani
NEW DELHI: Union home minister Amit Shah on Wednesday offered to sit in Parliament from 3pm till 3pm the next day to hear the Opposition’s concerns and respond to every point, as the standoff over alleged police excesses against student protesters continued.Shah’s offer came amid Opposition protests demanding that he make a statement in Parliament on the alleged police action against students during their July 20 march over the NEET paper leak issue.Speaking to reporters, Shah rejected Opposition allegations that he had been absent from Parliament and said the government was ready for a detailed discussion on the issue.“First of all, terms like ‘laapata’, ‘bhaag gaye’ are the kind of language increasingly being heard in India’s public and parliamentary life. I have been coming to Parliament regularly since the session began; I sit in my chamber, but since the opposition is not allowing Parliament to function—in either House—what is one supposed to do?” Shah said.He said Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju had already made it clear that the government was ready for a full discussion on the student protests.“We asked for a time to be fixed and for the Opposition to be ready. That was their initial demand, and we agreed to it. I, too, have stated that I am ready to answer any question in Parliament, yet they simply do not want the discussion to take place,” Shah said.“Now, let the public decide who is running away. Let them submit a letter to the Speaker by 3:00 PM today. We are ready for a discussion on all aspects from 3:00 PM today until 3:00 PM tomorrow. I will sit in the House; I will listen to everyone and respond to every point. The government has nothing to hide,” he added.Shah said he was even willing to discuss why the Opposition had not allowed the debate to take place.“The NDA government—under Modi ji’s leadership is ready to discuss anything; they just need to let Parliament function,” he said.Elaborating on his offer, Shah said, “I want to tell the opposition: submit a letter to the Speaker by 2:00 PM, we will start the discussion at 3:00 PM, and I will provide answers to everything by 3:00 PM tomorrow.”“There are established rules and procedures for parliamentary discussions. Yet, some ask me to simply make a statement. Such a serious issue cannot be discussed in that manner. That may be your method, but it is not the parliamentary way. In Parliament, discussions are held at length,” he said.“In Parliament, discussions are held at length. I am ready for the debate to continue from 3:00 PM today—sitting late into the night and continuing until 3:00 PM tomorrow; I am even prepared to suspend the Question Hour if the Speaker grants permission,” Shah said.“I am ready for the discussion to go on until 3:00 PM tomorrow. I will sit through it myself, take notes on everything, and respond to every point so that the entire matter becomes clear to the people of the country—so that the truth is fully revealed. Now, the Opposition must decide whether they want to engage in a discussion or create an uproar,” he added.Rahul Gandhi hits backLeader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi rejected Shah’s offer, saying the Opposition was seeking answers on the alleged police action against students rather than a lecture from the home minister.“The Opposition has clearly said that we are not interested in Amit Shah giving us a lecture. When I say ‘we’, I mean the younger generation of this country. Who shot the students? Who gave the order to beat up the students with lathis with nails? Did Amit Shah give this order to shoot our children? If he did, then he should resign. For the last 20 days, Amit Shah has been missing. The Home Minister of India has no courage; he cannot come to the House,” Rahul said.“Did Home Minister Shah give orders to shoot our children or not; if he did, he is culpable and if he did not, he is incompetent: Rahul Gandhi,” he added.The Opposition has been demanding Shah’s presence in Parliament and a statement on the alleged police excesses against students.Earlier in the day, Opposition MPs, including Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge and party general secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, staged a protest in the Parliament House Complex over the alleged theft of donations at the Ram temple in Ayodhya and the alleged police excesses against student protesters.Priyanka also questioned the government over the alleged use of force against students.“Who do you think is responsible for this? Are you (Home Minister Amit Shah) not answerable to the people when you lathi-charge students and use pellet guns against them, and use AK-47 on them in Bihar? Should we sit quietly like you all (the media)?” she said.The INDIA bloc has been protesting for more than three weeks, demanding Shah’s presence in the House and a statement from him.Government, Opposition remain at oddsThe government’s offer of a debate and Shah’s response failed to break the stalemate, with the Congress insisting that the home minister specifically address who ordered the alleged use of pellet guns against students.The Congress has also maintained that its demand for a discussion on the alleged theft of funds at the Ram temple is “non-negotiable”.Earlier on Monday, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju said the government was ready for a detailed discussion on the student protests and urged the Opposition not to disrupt proceedings when Shah responds.“The offer made by the government is very clear that it is ready to have a full and detailed discussion on students’ movement and activities related to it,” Rijiju said.“My only point made to the opposition is that while the discussion and a reply are being made, the opposition should not create disturbances to prevent the statement of the Home Minister,” he added. “They must listen to the reply of the home minister and the government.
Share your thoughts in the comments
Be respectful · TOI community guidelines
Once discussion begins, we must have a threadbare discussion.”Rijiju’s remarks came after Rahul Gandhi criticised the Centre over the alleged police action during the July 20 student protests at Jantar Mantar and demanded a court-monitored probe.Parliament proceedings have repeatedly been disrupted during the Monsoon Session, with several Bills passed by the Lok Sabha amid the continuing deadlock.
