Parimal Nathwani (PTI photo) NEW DELHI: National Democratic Alliance (NDA)-backed Independent candidate Parimal Nathwani won one of the two Jharkhand Rajya Sabha seats in a closely contested election that saw rival camps lock horns as the outcome remained open-ended.In the polls that witnessed cross-voting, Nathwani polled 28 votes, comfortably bypassing Congress’s Pranav, who bagged 20 votes.The ruling Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) candidate Baidyanath Ram was elected to the other seat.Ram received 30 votes in the election, while three votes, two from the BJP and one from the Congress, were found invalid, the official told news agency PTI.Congress minister Deepika Pandey reacting to the results, said that “dhoka hua” (Betrayed). BJP’s Koderma MLA Neera Yadav, on the contrary said: “Jai Shree Ram, ho gaya kaam”.The BJP-led NDA with 24 MLAs, was four short of the minimum of 28 first-preference votes required in the 81-member assembly to secure a berth in the Upper House of Parliament.ALSO READ | Rs 50 crore each? Meet 6 MPs who could decide the fate of Uddhav Thackeray’s Shiv SenaThe ruling INDIA bloc, including the JMM and the Congress, went to polls with 56 members in the assembly. The ruling INDIA bloc had the exact number of votes needed to win two Rajya Sabha seats, but what should have been an easy election for the NDA’s rival bloc turned into a keen contest with the BJP-led NDA deciding to enter the fray through an independent candidate despite not having enough numbers to win a seat on its own.Congress cries ‘betrayal’Jharkhand Congress in-charge K Raju, who served as the polling agent for the election, blamed alliance partners RJD and CPI(ML) Liberation for the party’s defeat.”RJD and CPI(ML) Liberation betrayed us. They didn’t vote for us, and that’s why we lost. We received JMM’s four votes, and all Congress legislators exercised their franchise in favour of our candidate,” Raju told PTI.When asked whether the outcome could affect the alliance, Raju said he would take up the issue with Chief Minister Hemant Soren.Jharkhand BJP president Aditya Sahu congratulated Parimal Nathwani on his victory and said legislators had voted according to their conscience.“Despite our two votes being invalid, Nathwani managed 28 votes. It is a big win. Even members in the India bloc have shown faith in development works being carried out under the leadership of our Prime Minister Narendra Modi,” Sahu said.Dismissing allegations of horse trading, he maintained that MLAs had exercised their franchise independently and in line with their conscience.Marandi says Jharkhand to benefitLeader of opposition Babulal Marandi said voters in Jharkhand, particularly BJP legislators, were mature and understood what was in the larger interest of the state.“Nathwani has been an MP from Jharkhand for two terms from 2008 to 2020. People have seen his work. He again got the opportunity to serve Jharkhand, and people will get its benefit,” said Marandi, a former chief minister.Former chief minister and BJP leader Champai Soren also welcomed Nathwani’s election and expressed confidence that he would help ensure the benefits of central welfare schemes reached the people of Jharkhand.Both the ruling and opposition camps left no stone unturned to keep their MLAs intact ahead of the polling.The NDA MLAs were shifted to a hotel in Ranchi on Tuesday, while the ruling INDIA bloc was busy holding meetings with its MLAs to thwart chances of cross-voting.The INDIA bloc MLAs, including those from the Congress, had participated in a mock poll during a meeting at chief minister Hemant Soren’s residence on Tuesday night to make the new legislators aware of the exercise, but it all ended in vain. ALSO READ | ‘Formidable ones subdued’: Uday Samant’s post fuels buzz over 6 Shiv Sena (UBT) MPs joining Eknath ShindeGet the latest India news and live updates. Download the TOI App.About the AuthorTOI News DeskThe TOI News Desk comprises a dedicated and tireless team of journalists who operate around the clock to deliver the most current and comprehensive news and updates to the readers of The Times of India worldwide. With an unwavering commitment to excellence in journalism, our team is at the forefront of gathering, verifying, and presenting breaking news, in-depth analysis, and insightful reports on a wide range of topics. The TOI News Desk is your trusted source for staying informed and connected to the ever-evolving global landscape, ensuring that our readers are equipped with the latest developments that matter most.”Read MoreEnd of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosPunjab CM Bhagwant Mann Claims Forensic Reports Vindicate Him In ‘Sacrilege’ Video RowUBT Crisis Deepens as Raut Claims Rebel MPs Got More Cash and Moved to Safe LocationBJP Leader Burnt Alive, 2 Others Killed Over Sand Mining Clash In ChhattisgarhCalcutta High Court Refuses Interim Relief to TMC, Ritabrata Banerjee Stays Leader of OppositionSix Shiv Sena (UBT) MPs Stay Away From Delhi Meet, Uddhav Camp on Edge As Defection Buzz IntensifiesVaiko-Vijay Meetings Trigger Buzz Over MDMK’s Future In Tamil Nadu’s Changing PoliticsModi-Starmer Confirm July 15 Launch Of Trade Pact Projected To Boost Bilateral CommerceJharkhand Rajya Sabha Polls Turn Into Numbers Battle As BJP Eyes Surprise Upset Against INDIA BlocDelhi-NCR Unveils Vision For Four New Cities As Population Set To Surge’Mother Of All Trade Deals’: India, EU Target FTA Signing Before End Of 2026123PhotostoriesMorning puffy face: Expert says it might be a sign of inflammation – how to fix itYoung men are spending more time in the gym: Doctors say their fertility may be paying the price5 mistakes couples often think are “normal” but can quietly damage love, as per relationship expertsMamta Mohandas to Hamsa Nandini: South Indian actors who battled and survived cancerWhat are Mathani and Hasua? 8 traditional kitchen tools missing from modern city kitchensTop parenting coach shares how to teach sons to choose the right friends at every age5 essential blood tests you should take before joining the gym, doctor revealsLegendary cricketer Jhulan Goswami’s home in Chakdaha, West Bengal is defined by simplicity, cricket memorabilia and family bond114-year-old barfi: This famous desi barfi was first made by a wrestler for personal nutrition5 highly venomous sea snakes found in Indian waters and where they are found123Hot PicksAaron Rodger ExCA TopperLionel MessiVaibhav SooryavanshiKannur University FYUGP TrialNFL Trade RumorsThomas TuchelWBJEE admit cardMP board second resultTop TrendingCristiano RonaldoIshan KishanShubham GillFIFA World Cup 2026What is Legacy BadgeDownload Optifine for Minecraft 26.2Aman SangerCBSE 10th Second Board Result 2026Eknath ShindeDevajit Saikia
NEW DELHI: National Democratic Alliance (NDA)-backed Independent candidate Parimal Nathwani won one of the two Jharkhand Rajya Sabha seats in a closely contested election that saw rival camps lock horns as the outcome remained open-ended.In the polls that witnessed cross-voting, Nathwani polled 28 votes, comfortably bypassing Congress’s Pranav, who bagged 20 votes.The ruling Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) candidate Baidyanath Ram was elected to the other seat.Ram received 30 votes in the election, while three votes, two from the BJP and one from the Congress, were found invalid, the official told news agency PTI.Congress minister Deepika Pandey reacting to the results, said that “dhoka hua” (Betrayed). BJP’s Koderma MLA Neera Yadav, on the contrary said: “Jai Shree Ram, ho gaya kaam“.The BJP-led NDA with 24 MLAs, was four short of the minimum of 28 first-preference votes required in the 81-member assembly to secure a berth in the Upper House of Parliament.ALSO READ | Rs 50 crore each? Meet 6 MPs who could decide the fate of Uddhav Thackeray’s Shiv SenaThe ruling INDIA bloc, including the JMM and the Congress, went to polls with 56 members in the assembly. The ruling INDIA bloc had the exact number of votes needed to win two Rajya Sabha seats, but what should have been an easy election for the NDA’s rival bloc turned into a keen contest with the BJP-led NDA deciding to enter the fray through an independent candidate despite not having enough numbers to win a seat on its own.
Congress cries ‘betrayal’
Jharkhand Congress in-charge K Raju, who served as the polling agent for the election, blamed alliance partners RJD and CPI(ML) Liberation for the party’s defeat.“RJD and CPI(ML) Liberation betrayed us. They didn’t vote for us, and that’s why we lost. We received JMM’s four votes, and all Congress legislators exercised their franchise in favour of our candidate,” Raju told PTI.When asked whether the outcome could affect the alliance, Raju said he would take up the issue with Chief Minister Hemant Soren.Jharkhand BJP president Aditya Sahu congratulated Parimal Nathwani on his victory and said legislators had voted according to their conscience.“Despite our two votes being invalid, Nathwani managed 28 votes. It is a big win. Even members in the India bloc have shown faith in development works being carried out under the leadership of our Prime Minister Narendra Modi,” Sahu said.Dismissing allegations of horse trading, he maintained that MLAs had exercised their franchise independently and in line with their conscience.
Marandi says Jharkhand to benefit
Leader of opposition Babulal Marandi said voters in Jharkhand, particularly BJP legislators, were mature and understood what was in the larger interest of the state.“Nathwani has been an MP from Jharkhand for two terms from 2008 to 2020. People have seen his work. He again got the opportunity to serve Jharkhand, and people will get its benefit,” said Marandi, a former chief minister.Former chief minister and BJP leader Champai Soren also welcomed Nathwani’s election and expressed confidence that he would help ensure the benefits of central welfare schemes reached the people of Jharkhand.Both the ruling and opposition camps left no stone unturned to keep their MLAs intact ahead of the polling.The NDA MLAs were shifted to a hotel in Ranchi on Tuesday, while the ruling INDIA bloc was busy holding meetings with its MLAs to thwart chances of cross-voting.The INDIA bloc MLAs, including those from the Congress, had participated in a mock poll during a meeting at chief minister Hemant Soren’s residence on Tuesday night to make the new legislators aware of the exercise, but it all ended in vain. ALSO READ | ‘Formidable ones subdued’: Uday Samant’s post fuels buzz over 6 Shiv Sena (UBT) MPs joining Eknath Shinde
