NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Thursday questioned the inclusion of a cabinet minister in the selection panel for the appointment of election commissioners, observing that a minister would not be able to go against the Prime Minister in the decision-making process.Hearing the matter related to the appointment process of the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners, the top court raised concerns over the composition of the panel, which currently includes the Prime Minister, the leader of 0pposition and a Union cabinet minister.The bench observed that decisions in such appointments would effectively be passed by a 2:1 majority, with the cabinet minister unlikely to differ from the Prime Minister’s stand.“Why this show off of independence in appointment of election commissioner,” the court remarked while questioning the present structure of the selection committee.The court further said that if the Chief Justice of India could be part of the appointment process for the director of the Central Bureau of Investigation, then there was no reason why an independent process could not be followed for the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners.The bench observed that the appointment process for the Election Commission was even more important as it directly concerned “upholding democracy and free and fair elections”.The court also underlined the importance of public confidence in the poll body’s impartiality, stating that the Election Commission of India “should not only be neutral but it should look neutral in its functioning”.About the AuthorTOI News DeskThe TOI News Desk comprises a dedicated and tireless team of journalists who operate around the clock to deliver the most current and comprehensive news and updates to the readers of The Times of India worldwide. With an unwavering commitment to excellence in journalism, our team is at the forefront of gathering, verifying, and presenting breaking news, in-depth analysis, and insightful reports on a wide range of topics. The TOI News Desk is your trusted source for staying informed and connected to the ever-evolving global landscape, ensuring that our readers are equipped with the latest developments that matter most.”Read MoreEnd of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosEx-Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee In Lawyer’s Gown Argues Post-poll Violence Case In High CourtKC Venugopal Backs VD Satheesan as Kerala CM, Says Congress Fully United Behind HimCongress Picks VD Satheesan as Kerala CM After 10 Days of Talks and Leadership BattleRBI Governor Warns Fuel Price Hike Possible If Middle East Crisis Continues LongerAIMIM Corporator’s Home Razed In Sambhajinagar Amid TCS Conversion Case Row EscalationKerala CM Race Ends as Congress Picks VD Satheesan Amid Venugopal Backing and Internal TensionsBJP Questions Rahul Gandhi Over Alleged Rs 60 Crore Foreign Travel Spending ClaimsIran Signals More Safe Passage For Indian Ships As BRICS Meet Faces West Asia DivideIndia-Bound 46,000 TONNES LPG Ship Cross Strait Of Hormuz, Two Ships In 48 Hours | WatchKabul Partners With Indian Company, Signs $46MN Deal To Upgrade Quality Control Across Trade Routes123Photostories5 oils you need to buy on your hair growth journey10 destinations in India that became viral sensations after featuring in Bollywood moviesThese Indian fruits have surprisingly different English names5 Indian states that consume the most petrol per person and why travellers should pay attentionCan Hantavirus spread between humans? Doctors reveal why this rare infection is nothing like Covid-197 foods Indian grandparents ate regularly that are suddenly trendy againThis Indian kitchen waste is secretly the best fertiliser for terrace gardensJupiter and Venus Come Together : These Star Signs Might Get A Text From Their Ex7 garden trends to steal from British gardeners and plant enthusiastsThe ‘cool roof garden’ trend taking over Indian apartments: Here’s how to start one123Hot PicksCBSE class 12 resultUS Iran warPrateek YadavHaryana election resultForeign outflowNEET exam cancelledTamil Nadu assemblyTop TrendingWB Class 12 Result 2026WB Board 12th ResultIPL Points TablePM Internship SchemeCalcutta High CourtMI vs PBKS IPL MatchIPL Orange Cap 2026Haryana Board ResultAir India FlightsPrateek Yadav
NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Thursday questioned the inclusion of a cabinet minister in the selection panel for the appointment of election commissioners, observing that a minister would not be able to go against the Prime Minister in the decision-making process.Hearing the matter related to the appointment process of the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners, the top court raised concerns over the composition of the panel, which currently includes the Prime Minister, the leader of 0pposition and a Union cabinet minister.The bench observed that decisions in such appointments would effectively be passed by a 2:1 majority, with the cabinet minister unlikely to differ from the Prime Minister’s stand.“Why this show off of independence in appointment of election commissioner,” the court remarked while questioning the present structure of the selection committee.The court further said that if the Chief Justice of India could be part of the appointment process for the director of the Central Bureau of Investigation, then there was no reason why an independent process could not be followed for the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners.The bench observed that the appointment process for the Election Commission was even more important as it directly concerned “upholding democracy and free and fair elections”.The court also underlined the importance of public confidence in the poll body’s impartiality, stating that the Election Commission of India “should not only be neutral but it should look neutral in its functioning”.